COMING SOON! PQDT Open is getting a new home!

ProQuest Open Access Dissertations & Theses will remain freely available as part of a new and enhanced search experience at

Questions? Please refer to this FAQ.

Dissertation/Thesis Abstract

Research on prisoners: An alternative to animal testing
by Abbate, Cheryl E., M.A., Colorado State University, 2011, 97; 1493747
Abstract (Summary)

Members of the biomedical community justify biomedical research on sentient beings by depicting the benign results which are regarded as necessary for scientific and medical progress, which in turn is absolutely necessary for maintaining human health, well being, and life. Rather than take for granted that the burden of biomedical research should rest only on nonhuman animals, I will explore whether or not there is a more appropriate class of sentient beings that we should conduct our biomedical research on. I will argue, based on utilitarian principles, that if we can maximize overall happiness by conducting our research on a different group of beings, then we should opt to conduct our biomedical experiments on these beings. My central proposal is that our decision to experiment on nonhuman animals is not the best alternative available; rather, if we were to experiment on violent criminals, we would increase overall happiness. Since conducting biomedical research on this particular group of prisoners would fulfill the aims of retributive punishment, deter violent crime, and procure optimal scientific results, we would produce the maximal amount of benefits by experimenting on these transgressors. Thus when faced with the choice to experiment on either violent criminals or nonhuman animals, the morally commendable decision would be to perform research on violent criminals.

Indexing (document details)
Advisor: Rollin, Bernard E.
Commitee: Cafaro, Phil, Hogan, Mike
School: Colorado State University
Department: Philosophy
School Location: United States -- Colorado
Source: MAI 49/06M, Masters Abstracts International
Subjects: Philosophy, Medical Ethics, Political science, Sociology
Keywords: Animal ethics, Biomedical research, Criminals, Experimenting on prisoners, Justice, Punishment
Publication Number: 1493747
ISBN: 978-1-124-66747-8
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. Terms and Conditions Privacy Policy Cookie Policy