Dissertation/Thesis Abstract

The Portrait Potential: Gender, Identity, and Devotion in Manuscript Owner Portraits, 1230-1320
by Doyle, Maeve, Ph.D., Bryn Mawr College, 2015, 274; 3720466
Abstract (Summary)

As the representation of specific, identifiable persons in art, portraiture often reflects ideas of selfhood or individuality while simultaneously participating in their construction. Since the introduction of physiognomic likeness into the visual language of western portraiture in the mid-fourteenth century, this quality has come to exemplify the portrait’s capacity to represent an individual subject. Yet, although likeness and portrait have become synonymous in modern parlance, portraiture as a form of representation predates the addition of likeness to its semiotic system. This dissertation explores the reception of portraits in the absence of physiognomic likeness through a study of medieval “owner portraits,” the deceptively simple representations of book owners in their prayer books. A group of eight illuminated books of hours and psalter-hours produced in northern France between 1230 and 1320 displaying a remarkable number of owner portraits provides a wealth of evidence for the study of the motif.

Although formulaic in appearance, owner portraits have the capacity to convey a range of identities that shift and expand based on the context of their reception. As the first chapter demonstrates, owner portraits signify identity by inviting the self-identification of their viewers, who recognize their own performances of piety anticipated in the images. This understanding allows for further deconstruction of the markers of identity embedded within the portrait image. The second chapter examines the gendered imagery of the owner portrait through the metaphor of the mirror, as medieval rhetoric feminized the act of introspective viewing associated with mirrors and books alike. Rather than faithful records of religious use, owner portraits must be understood as ideological images that construct literate devotion in the Middle Ages as a feminine activity. The third chapter explores further the issues of gender and identity in manuscripts that juxtapose male and female owner figures. In representing distinct masculine and feminine modes of prayer alongside one another, such manuscripts invite cross-gendered reception of owner images, even while asserting essentialist modes of devotion. The final chapter addresses the effects of repetition specific to this group of manuscripts. Portraits repeated throughout a book evoke a ritual time that collapses not only past and present, but also future. In looking to the future, the portraits embrace their subjects’ mortality, accommodating reception by later viewers while also promising eternal life.

The manuscripts discussed in this work include: the Aspremont-Kievraing Prayer Book (Oxford, Bodleian Library MS Douce 118 and Melbourne, National Gallery of Victoria inv. 1254-3); the Baltimore-Paris Psalter-Hours (Baltimore, Walters Art Museum MS W.113 and Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France MS nouv. acq. lat. 915); the Cambrai Hours (Cambrai, Médiathèque municipale MS 87); the de Brailes Hours (London, British Library Add. MS 49999); the Franciscan Psalter-Hours (Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France MS lat. 1076 and Marseille, Bibliothèque municipale MS 111); the Margaret Hours (London, British Library Add. 36684 and New York, Morgan Library MS M.754); the Metz Psalter-Hours (Metz, Bibliothèques-médiathèques MS 1588); the Morgan Hours (New York, Morgan Library MS M.92); and a book of hours in the collection of Renate König, Cologne.

Indexing (document details)
Advisor: Kinney, Dale
Commitee: Armstrong, Grace M., Easton, Martha, Hertel, Christiane, Perkinson, Stephen, Walker, Alicia
School: Bryn Mawr College
Department: History of Art
School Location: United States -- Pennsylvania
Source: DAI-A 77/01(E), Dissertation Abstracts International
Subjects: Art history, Medieval history, Gender studies
Keywords: Communication and the arts, Illuminated manuscripts, Portraiture, Prayer books, Reception of art, Selfhood and identity
Publication Number: 3720466
ISBN: 978-1-339-01466-1
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. Terms and Conditions Privacy Policy Cookie Policy